Hatchery Salmon Damaging Wild Fish Stocks By Outcompeting Them For Food

Hatchery salmon stocks have long been used to “mitigate” the damage to wild salmon stocks caused by habitat loss, dams, water quality issues and others.

A growing body of evidence suggests they’re not simply mitigating the damage to wild stocks, but actually causing it:

The ocean’s a pretty big place, right? Maybe not big enough for wild salmon and hatchery salmon to share, according to new research.

A special issue in the journal Environmental Biology of Fishes looks at how hatcheries are affecting wild fish populations. Research for the issue came from scientists around the Pacific Ocean – from Japan to California.

One of the major findings: hatchery fish may be outcompeting wild fish for food in the Bering Sea.

That area is a feeding hot-spot for chum salmon – where fish that came from hatcheries mix and mingle with wild fish.

With millions more hatchery salmon arriving at the feeding grounds, there’s not enough to go around and the researchers say that contributed to a significant drop in the wild chum population.

With California’s wild salmon and steelhead populations in decline, hatcheries remain a reality, though better, more thoughtful approaches are needed — especially those emphasizing the restoration of wild fish populations (via habitat restoration, rewatering, water quality fixes, etc).

– Protect & Restore, CalTrout

Spring Storms Improve California’s Snowpack… A Little…

A string of spring storms (OK, those of us living through them have used far-less-charitable words) have moved the needle a little on California’s snowpack — mostly in the northern end of the state.

The central and southern Sierras are still running a huge deficit, but the the Northern part of the state is creeping up.

California Snowpack Chart

California Snowpack as of 4/13/2012 (click image for latest figures)

It’s still going to be a tough water year for California — whose water resources are severely overcommitted — but it is better than the 40% of normal numbers we were looking at a month ago.

California’s Dismal Snowpack/Waterpack Numbers Tick Up Ever So Slightly

A weeklong series of storms have bumped California’s snowpack/waterpack up from the truly dismal to the depressing.

The southern Sierras remain at only 37% of normal for this time of the year (the water year ends on April 1) while the Central and Northern Sierras are doing a bit better (45% and 53% respectively).

California snowpack

California's drought looks certain (click graph for latest numbers)

As always, already-stressed fish populations suffer bigger hits during drought years than is the case with healthier populations.

California’s Dry Winter Continues; A Drought Year Looms

California’s vital snowpack has fallen to approximately 30% of normal for this time of year, and with no real storms on the horizon, it looks to keep falling for another week.

California Snowpack Map

Statewide, we're at 30% of normal and falling (click map for latest numbers)

We may enjoy some benefit from the two prior winters (which were wetter than normal), but with California’s water supply overpromised several times over, it could be a hard year for fish and growers.

2011: CalTrout’s Year in Pictures

We’re putting together our “CalTrout’s Year In Review” email right now, but while we’re waiting, we thought we’d feature a few of the pretty and interesting photographs from 2011 that highlighted important stories.

In no particular order…

Big Springs Salmon

Big Springs Salmon

The return of salmon to restored Big Springs was a big story in 2011

The recovery of Coho salmon on the Shasta, Scott and Klamath Rivers remained an important story in 2011, especially on the Nature Conservancy-owned Big Springs ranch, which provides critical Coho salmon rearing habitat.

This photograph of a Big Springs salmon was taken at the Nature Conservancy open house in October.

Lake Tahoe Invasives

Jenny Hatch and Lake Tahoe Koi

24" Koi don't belong in Lake Tahoe...

One of the more striking images of 2011 came courtesy an electro-shocking survey in Lake Tahoe Marina, which turned up a 24″ Koi.

CalTrout Northern Sierra Region Manager Jenny Hatch was part of the crew, and the picture remains a stark reminder of the invasive issues facing California’s native trout.

The Val Atkinson Interview

Val Atkins, California's best-known fishing photographer?

Our Val Atkinson interview remains one of the most-visited stories of 2011

We ran an interview of longtime CalTrout supporter and nationally known outdoor photographer Val Atkinson, and while the frank, interesting interview was one of the most-read articles of the year, this picture generated comments and emails like no other.

California’s Golden Trout

California Golden Trout

California's Golden Trout may have recovered enough to avoid ESA listing

While California’s Golden Trout are clearly still in some peril, recovery efforts have succeeded to the point that when the US Fish & Wildlife service decided it didn’t warrant an Endangered Species Listing, CalTrout was cautiously supportive.

This photo — sent to us by CalTrout member Scott Chandler — is a reminder of what’s at stake. We remain watchful, but optimistic that the current collaborative approach is working.

Hey, Our ED Fishes

CalTrout Executive Director Jeff Thompson

We work for fishermen...

While it was taken in 2010 (New Zealand), this picture illustrates a compelling reality about CalTrout’s Executive Director. He fly fishes.

The Casting Call

The 2nd Annual CalTrout/TU Casting Call

The 2nd Annual CalTrout/TU Casting Call

Our 2nd annual Casting Call offered California’s legislators a chance to hear from us about important legislative issues, and does so in a lighthearted (nay, we say “fun”), nonpartisan environment.

(Well, not entirely nonpartisan; it featured a “Cast Off” between three Republican and three Democratic legislators.)

Those interested in a Mikey Weir video of the event should click here.

The McCloud Video Thing

The McCloud hydro relicensing story was one of the biggest stories of 2011, and in order to keep our membership informed about what was going on (especially in the face of some misinformation), we created a simple screencast that neatly illustrated the benefits of the proposed new McCloud flow regime (and in only five minutes too):

Forty Years

CalTrout celebrated forty years protecting and restoring California’s coldwater trout, steelhead and salmon. To see where it all began, watch our 40th Anniversary Video:

More To Come in 2012

We’re proud of what we accomplished in 2011, including the re-launch of our website and online presence.

And we fully expect next year’s “Year in Review” and “Year in Pictures” articles will highlight even more success protecting and restoring California’s wild trout, steelhead and salmon waters.

It’s Too Early To Call It A Drought, But Northern California’s Snowpack Almost Nonexistent

The snow has yet to really fly in the Northern California, and while many ski resorts are feeling the heat, the state’s fly fishermen are also keeping a wary eye on the weather.

After all, this winter’s snow becomes next year’s trout, steelhead and salmon water. The Snotel map suggests the whole west is suffering (click map image for updated map):

Snotel screen

Drought? Or just late start to winter?

Keep in mind that much last year’s record snowpack fell in March, so while the forecast predicts no storms in the next week, a comeback is not out of the question.

Study Reports Hatchery Salmon, Steelhead Damaging Wild Fish Genetics

Researchers are reporting that hatchery-bred steelhead and salmon (West Coast) are far less productive in the wild than wild fish, and that the “domestication” of steelhead takes place at an extremely rapid pace — often in a single generation.

It’s yet another

Researchers created an enormous fish family tree using genetic samples from 12,700 steelhead trout (which are in the same family as salmon) returning from the sea to Oregon’s Hood River to spawn. This fishy pedigree revealed the fish that spawned well in hatcheries had offspring that spawned poorly in the wild.

“They’re adapting to captivity in a single generation,” study scientist Mark Christie, a postdoctoral researcher at Oregon State University, told LiveScience. In other words, the fish rapidly became domesticated, Christie and his colleagues reported Monday in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

What’s happening?

The traits that allows steelhead and salmon to thrive in hatcheries are not the same traits that allow them to thrive in the wild:

They found when fish produced higher-than-average numbers of offspring in the hatchery, the offspring of those offspring had just 71 percent the number of babies as fish born in the wild. In other words, whatever it is that makes baby fish thrive and survive in the hatchery is not beneficial in the real world.

Scientists have long argued that hatcheries — while propping up populations — were actually harming the overall productivity of west coast steelhead and salmon, and that management for wild fish populations is needed.

It’s also an argument for dam removal where native populations are cut off from spawning habitat and hatchery fish are used to bolster fish numbers — the situation on the Klamath River’s severely impaired salmon and steelhead populations.

Over the long term, hatchery fish genes will damage the productivity of the population as a whole.

With Sadness, We Note The Passing of Martin Seldon

It is with sadness that CalTrout notes the passing of Martin Seldon, a founding CalTrout Director, FFF luminary, and dogged advocate for our fisheries.

Marty established a scholarship program so students could attend the Wild Trout Symposium, and this is his bio from that scholarship page:

Marty has played a long and active role as an advocate of wild trout, and has been an enthusiastic volunteer for the Wild Trout Symposium Organizing Committee since Wild Trout-II in 1979.

Over the years Marty has been active on the Photography, Awards, and Program Committees, and has chaired the Awards Committee for WT-VII and WT-VIII, and served as its co-chair for WT-IX in 2007. Marty has continued to be active on the Organizing Committee for WT-X.

Among many others, he received the Federation of Fly Fishers’ highest honor, The Order of the Lapis Lazuli Award. He was also the Wild Trout Symposium’s first nonprofessional category Aldo Starker Leopold Wild Trout Medal recipient at Wild Trout-III in 1984.

Marty’s long involvement in wild trout conservation began in the 1960’s, when Marty wrote fishing columns for San Francisco and Central Valley fishing newspapers and was Angler Magazine Conservation Editor. Over the year’s Marty has written extensively on catch-and-release fishing.

Marty has served as a Trout Unlimited chapter president, was a founding director of CalTrout, and has been a Federation of Fly Fishers (FFF) volunteer since 1972. Marty has also served as the Conservation Vice President of the Northern California Council FFF and from 1976-1986 was on the FFF Executive Committee as Senior Vice President Conservation.

He has been Chairman of the FFF International Relations and Fish and Wildlife Committees, and managed several FFF fly fishing industry databases. He is presently a FFF Northern California/Northern Nevada Council Director, and a FFF Senior Advisor.

CalTrout’s Executive Director’s Update

[Ed's Note: This originally appeared in the Fall print version of CalTrout Streamkeeper's Log newsletter]

Over the last few weeks, I’ve had opportunities to meet with a number of folks with a keen interest in CalTrout, our mission and our work: fly fishing guides, fly shop staff, fly club leaders, UC Davis science partners, California state senators, CalTrout donors, and one of our founders (Richard May). I enjoy the feedback, appreciate the dialogue, and find it all incredibly informative.

Two of the topics frequently discussed were: “What did CalTrout accomplish this year?” and “How do you know whether it was a good year for the organization?”

Starting with the former — and despite working on many long-term horizon projects (i.e., 2020 Klamath dam removal) — we’ve made progress on a number of critical initiatives:

  • Eel River Fish Passage: We will wrap up an assessment of almost 60 fish passage barriers on the Eel River, many of which will be removed/reconfigured in coming years to improve access to prime spawning habitat.
  • Klamath River: CalTrout, the only organization of its kind with offices in the Klamath region, has been focused on building local community support for the critical removal of four dams.
  • Southern California Steelhead Coalition: CalTrout has taken on the leadership role among 40+ local conservation organizations to deliver coordinated steelhead recovery programs across five southern California watersheds.
  • McCloud Dam Re-licensing: We secured … gained FERC and DFG approval on slight flow changes — better for fish in the winter while preserving the McCloud’s exceptional fishing experience during the fishing season.
  • McCloud/Mt Shasta Springs: CalTrout helped complete a $1M springs study (sponsored by Nestle) that better informs the management of a critical and unique water source.
  • Hat Creek: By year end, we will complete a comprehensive Hat Creek restoration plan aimed at restoring a world renowned spring creek.
    Golden Trout De-listing: Successful efforts of CalTrout, TU and Chevron among others resulted in the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service’s decision not to list California’s unique golden trout as a threatened or endangered species.

These are but a few of the 30 some odd conservation programs CalTrout has in place around the state, in addition to our ongoing advocacy and policy work in Sacramento.

Regarding whether “it was a good year for the organization,” I simply answer the question this way; we are doing more work and more impactful work on a statewide scale than ever in CalTrout’s 40-year history.

Our membership base is 7,500 strong and growing. At a time when many conservation focused non-profits have been struggling financially, CalTrout’s financial health and balance sheet have never been stronger.

We appreciate your support and we continue to spend your contributions wisely on behalf of California’s wild trout, steelhead, salmon and their waters.

Tight lines (and an early Happy Holidays)
JTsignature
Jeff Thompson, CalTrout Executive Director

California Chapter of Trout Unlimited Names Brian Johnson Director

From the Trout Unlimited, California Chapter website:

Brian Johnson, who for six years headed up the California Water Project for Trout Unlimited (TU), has been named the new Director of California TU. Johnson succeeds Chuck Bonham, who was recently appointed as the Director of the California Fish and Game Department.

“Brian’s intellect, expertise and quick wit have won the respect of many people both within and outside of Trout Unlimited,” says Rob Masonis, TU’s Vice President for Western Conservation. “I am confident that the California Program will thrive with Brian’s steady hand at the wheel, and he is eager to take on his new responsibilities.”

Brian’s success at TU and many other professional accomplishments position him well to lead TU’s California Program. During the 1990s, he served in the White House environmental office as its communications director and he co-created the successful “Energy Star” program at EPA. After attending law school at Stanford University, he worked for several years as an attorney at Shute, Mihaly & Weinberger, one of California’s premier natural resources law firms, before joining TU. Brian is a graduate of Duke University and lives in San Francisco with his wife Debbie and children Leo and Veronica.

Brian and his team look forward to working with you to protect and restore California’s salmon and trout, and the watersheds in which they live.